Is buying backlinks a good idea? What Google calls link spam

No. Paying for links so you rank higher is exactly what Google's spam policies call link spam, and the policy says sites that break it "may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all."

A cheap package is the riskiest version: you can't see where the links go, and you can't take them back. The links that help a local business are the ones people give you because you're real.

What does a cheap backlink offer look like?

It usually arrives as an email or a marketplace listing. Something like 100 backlinks for $20, all high authority, permanent and delivered in a week. The pitch is that Google counts links, so more links means higher rankings.

Half of that is true. Google does use links. Its SEO Starter Guide says PageRank, which uses links, is one of its fundamental algorithms, and then adds that "PageRank is just one of those" ranking signals. The other half is the problem. A link that exists only because someone was paid to place it is the specific thing Google set out to ignore or punish.

Here's the question I'd ask before paying anything: where will these 100 links live? Nobody selling them at 20 cents each is calling a newspaper.

What does Google actually call link spam?

Google defines it in one sentence in its spam policies: "Link spam is the practice of creating links to or from a site primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings." The examples that follow read like the inside of a cheap package.

What the offer saysWhat Google's spam policy lists
Buy 100 backlinks"Buying or selling links for ranking purposes," including "Exchanging money for links, or posts that contain links"
Fast, automated delivery"Using automated programs or services to create links to your site"
Directory and bookmark submissions"Low-quality directory or bookmark site links"
Guest posts with your keyword as anchor"links with optimized anchor text in articles, guest posts, or press releases distributed on other sites"
Link exchange, I link to you, you link to me"Excessive link exchanges"

The policy isn't against paying for visibility. Google says buying and selling links is "a normal part of the economy of the web for advertising and sponsorship purposes," and that it's fine as long as the link is marked. The marking is a rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow" attribute. Google's page on qualifying outbound links asks sites to mark "advertisements or paid placements (commonly called paid links)" with the sponsored value.

So a paid link that says it's paid is allowed. It just doesn't pass ranking credit. A cheap package sells you the opposite: a paid link pretending not to be one.

What happens if Google catches it?

The policy gives the range. Google detects violations "both through automated systems and, as needed, human review that can result in a manual action." And then: "Sites that violate our policies may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all."

There's a quieter outcome too, and it's the more common way the money disappears. Google's page on spam updates explains that when its systems remove the effect of spammy links, "any ranking benefit the links may have previously generated for your site is lost." The same paragraph says those benefits "cannot be regained." You paid for something that got switched off, and you won't get an email about it.

I'll be honest about the other side. Spam sometimes ranks for a while. Owners and agencies post threads like this one on the Local Search Forum, about a lawyer whose links look like a link wheel and who still ranks first. I don't doubt it happens. But you can't tell from the outside how long it lasts, and the bill for being wrong lands on the business, not on whoever sold the links.

Are free "dofollow" link lists any better?

Usually not. In October we went through a public list of 49 sites promoted as free dofollow backlinks. I opened each one with curl and read the actual link code on a sample page.

What I found: 47 of the 49 were still online. I could confirm a followed link on only 11 of them. And 6 of those 11 were exactly the kind of site Google names in its policy: submission directories, bookmarking sites that sell themselves as dofollow, and promotion networks sitting next to gambling and pirated streaming pages. My verdict on the whole list was 1 worth doing, 3 maybe and 45 no.

Free or cheap, the pattern is the same. When a link is easy to get for anyone, it's easy to get for spammers too, and that's the company your site ends up in.

Which links actually help a local business?

The ones that exist because of something real you did. Google's Starter Guide says "Other sites linking to you is something that happens naturally over time," and it suggests promotion through community engagement, word of mouth and offline materials. For a local practice, that translates into a short list:

  • Professional associations. Your state bar, a therapists' directory run by a licensing or professional body, your CPA society. Check whether the member directory has a website field.
  • Local press. A quote in a local news story about your field, or a piece about a free workshop you ran. One of these is worth more than any package.
  • Suppliers and partners. The software you use, the coworking space where you rent an office, the referral partner who already sends you clients. Ask whether they have a partners or clients page.
  • Clients with websites. A business client who's happy with your work may mention you on their own site. Ask once, and never pay or trade for it.
  • Your own community. A talk at the chamber of commerce, a sponsorship of a local event. If the link is part of a sponsorship, it should be marked as sponsored, and that's fine.

None of this is fast. All of it is safe, and most of it also brings people, not just links. Links also feed your Google Business Profile: Google's local ranking help says prominence is "also based on info like how many websites link to your business" and how many reviews you have.

Before you chase links from outside, make sure your own site points to the right pages. A new service page that nothing on your site links to won't be helped much by outside links either, and how to find and fix orphan pages covers that in ten minutes.

Questions I get about this

I already bought links. What should I do?
Stop buying more, and list what you can find: where they are and what they cost. If you have a manual action in Search Console, the report tells you what Google found. If you don't, the links may already count for nothing. I can't promise a fix, and anyone who promises a quick one is selling again.

Is a paid directory listing link spam?
Not automatically. Paying to be listed is advertising. The question is whether the listing brings you clients, and I compare paid directories with owning the answer in paying to be on a list vs being the answer.

How many backlinks does a local business need?
There's no number I'd trust. A few links from your association, a local paper and two partners can do more than hundreds from sites nobody reads.

Sources

All pages were read on November 10, 2026. The numbers about the free link list are mine: I checked the 49 sites on October 7, 2026, reading the link code on one sample page per site, with no paid tools. If you'd rather I look at the links you already have and the ones worth earning, that's part of the audit, or you can book a strategic fit call and we'll look at it together.

Next
Next

Can an SEO agency guarantee first page rankings?